1. Thornton listed the differences between mainstream ideologies and subculture ideologies with a schema on P115. Is it an indication that Club culture holds its distinction based on discrimination towards mainstream ideologies? How to understand the relation between such a distinction and discrimination? And does this schema accurately and inclusively reveal all the differences between club culture ideologies and popular ideologies? Among the 12 factors, which do you think is most essential one for these clubber and raver to identify “US” from “THEM”?
2. According to Thornton, even though clubber or raver claim their culture as classless, they use subcultual capital as the linchpin of an alternative hierarchy “in which the axes of age, gender, sexuality and race are all employed in order to keep the determinations of class, income and occupation at bay”(P105). To be specific, “despite their discourses of liberty, raves had distinct demographics-chiefly white, working-class, heterosexual and dominated by the lads.”( P25) And there are 3 principles in the organization of club: self-selection, routes of communication, and door policy (P110-114). At this point, can we assume club culture has comparatively more "autonomy”? Can we say that club culture maintains absolute “classlessness”? And can clubs and raves democratize youth culture? Why/ Why not? Considering its social meaning, does the “hierarchy” in club culture equal to “class” in mainstream culture to indicate status? How to understand the relation between the two from the perspective of social logic of cultural capital and subcultural capital?
3. Thornton talked about various media (mass media, micro media, and niche media) involved in the formation of club cultures. On P90, Thornton mentioned a typical club whose culture is outlaw but its antagonist “is not the police but the media who continually threaten to release its cultural knowledge to other social groups”. So positive tabloid coverage is “the subcultural kiss of death” (P135). On the other hand, “mass media ‘misunderstanding’ is often an objective of certain subcultual industries, rather an accident of youth cultural pursuit.” (P136) Does it mean that club and rave can take advantage of or even seek for negative reporting and avoid “positive tabloid coverage” for its further development? How can clubs and raves invoke the negative reporting against positive coverage? How can they control the tongue of media coverage? Is it risky for subculture to get media involved?

No comments:
Post a Comment