Much of the discussion in this course has centered on taste distinctions. These tastes are often manifested in the alternative media a particular audience favors, who seek out avant-garde circles that share their tastes. It seems to me that the so-called independents of the film industry define success by getting their product out to the most amounts of people possible, which is done by exploiting the channels of the mainstream film distribution apparatus. Until recently, independent films and mainstream films were indiscernible aesthetically, since at any given point a majority of mainstream films were made by independent filmmakers. My question is then; does an independent film offer viewers a taste distinction at all, since the means that all films are brought to the public is almost always through the same mainstream channels?
The film industry offers the most unique discourse on the independent/mainstream dichotomy. The mainstream is often represented simply through the economic advantages they hold, as they are the ones that own the means of distribution. However, they are fundamentally dependent on the indie producers for the content. Without the mainstream, the independents would not have a cohesive distribution apparatus, and without the independents, the mainstream would have less content to distribute. The relationship between independent and mainstream filmmaking is, and apparently has always been, functionally symbiotic. The independents are constantly trying to out-mainstream the mainstream by creating films that are more attractive to massive audiences in order to gain enough capital to compete with the majors, but since they ultimately depend on those majors for distribution, is this a futile effort? Is it not irrational to believe that the independent media can use the mainstream distribution channels to compete with the mainstream?
Since the studios and the independent producers are essentially linked in the business of making films, it becomes hard to understand exactly what an independent film looks like. The Tzioumakis (I just wanted you to have to say his name in your head) book goes to great lengths to discuss the films that were produced independently, and even when he does explain the aesthetical nuances of indie films, he fails to mention mainstream studio films that were aesthetically similar to the indies (I imagine there had to be some). In the case of Juno, a movie I have no problem saying I loved, the subject matter is nothing new for

No comments:
Post a Comment