Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Céline week, more videos



"I Don't Need Anything But You," from the 1999 ABC TV movie version of Annie. This is schmaltz.



Céline sings in French 1998, "S'il suffisait d'aimer" live.



Céline sings in French 1988, Eurovision contest, "Ne partez pas sans moi."



New Found Glory, "My Heart Will Go On" (a punk cover...ironic?).

Let's talk about Celine and tastes

1. In the first two chapters Wilson mentions the story of Celine and Elliott, and how things got personal to him at the Oscars. From what Wilson states, he gives me a feeling that there are always gaps between mainstream pop stars and underground artists, and the tastes of each other are always mutually exclusive. Then at the end of the second chapter, he introduces the story that Wilson was defending Celine Dion in front of others who dislike Celine. All of these make me think about the relation between “tastes and interpersonal relationships.” I guess my question is does people having different tastes really matter that much? Does having different tastes really hinder interpersonal relationships? If not, why we are paying so much attention to it? It seems that people always like to manifest or declare their own tastes, the my-taste-is-better-than-your-taste postures. It seems like people believe what we consume is always a representation of who we are. Yeah, people do have different tastes, but so what? Why we like to make “taste” such a big deal?

2. In chapter four “Let’s Talk About World Conquest”, Wilson brings up the case of Celine in China (P40). “What’s the biggest misconception the Chinese had about the West?” “The Chinese believe Celine Dion makes good music.” “Out of the whole catalog of American, Canadian and British music, the Chinese seem to enjoy primarily four artists: Dion, Mariah Carey, Elton John and Kenny G.” It’s really interesting when I read to this point. I guess one thing I’m thinking about is the marketing strategies. It’s all about accessibility. If Celine and Mariah are all that Chinese media present, these are all that Chinese audiences can get. Wilson wants the Chinese to appreciate Elliott, but I’m sorry, no major Chinese media inform us that there is an Elliott. Another observation of mine is that it seems that Chinese music lovers are more critical/ skeptical about our own Chinese pop music, but hold more open attitudes (even worships) toward western pop music/ stars, just like Americans are more critical about their own pop culture, but maybe more easy-going to Japanese/ French pop culture. They say “distance creates beauty.” Do you think it can be fit in this case—tastes of Chinese fans and Celine? I guess the point I’m trying to make is that the nature of taste is really a complicated matter. One cannot just stand at one place and give the judgments about what is good and what is bad. What do you think regarding this?

3. Just one simple question: People generally think Celine’s French songs are much better than her English songs. Not only Wilson thinks so, but her fan says her French work “seems to have a deeper soul or meaning of it (P109).” Why is that? Let’s put aside the issue of taste, why do people generally enjoy her French songs better? Is it simply because she’s better at conveying her emotions through French?

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Celine Dion has got to go - - I've got to Go Celine Dion

So, given the (perhaps) less than critical/scholarly tone of Wilson's book i would like to pose a series of (again perhaps) slightly less-than-purely-scholarly questions to this work (please note that while reading Wilson's book has somehow actually made me pause to consider the fact that i might actually like Celine Dion {and/or her music} my questions run on the assumption that we all start from the point of view of hating her music):

.08 . In chapter 6 Wilson introduces the concepts of the 'genuine fake' and 'authentic inauthenticity', which (to me at least) bring to mind these ideas we've mentioned of indie culture searching for its "authenticity" in older medium (vinyl, black & white film, lo-fi). Is it a fair assumption to accept these terms, but not consider the 'fake genuine' or 'inauthentic authenticity' as equally valid 'positions'?

1. On p. 67 Wilson ventures into questions about finding 'the self' & the "self-assemblage" that makes up modern identity. I wonder if the complex "bricolage" of self-identity isn't simplified in every kind of fandom (mainstream or indie), so that rather than having to create a version of 'the self' for every given situation, a fandom (and maybe especially an indie fandom) fashions a specific posture (say an ironic posture) to cover all sorts of social situations. Can we consider conformity (rather than the 'bad' mainstream sort or the unacknowledged indie sort) to taste cultures simply a way of managing the complex nature of modern social interaction?

2. At the very end of chapter 5, Wilson gives us a version of why Dion will never enjoy an ironic indie revival: "schmalz...is never purely escapist: it is not just cathartic but socially reinforcing" and so it "rots faster than other ingredients in the musical pantry" (61). First of all, this assumes that schmalz (and perhaps any unseemly outpouring of emotion) is trying to be escapist, ignoring possibilities for it to be, say, subversive, but the conclusion also ignores a 'schmalzy' artist who did enjoy a revival like, say, William Shatner whose acting could quite easily be characterized as 'schmalzy' and whose first "musical" foray was what i might categorize as experimental schmalz. In 2004, though, Shatner (and Ben Folds) released Has Been, an album that (at least somewhat) revives Shatner's career & 'indie cred'. Who gets to decide what can be retrospectively appreciated (albeit ironically) & what gets re-invented (read co-opted)?

2.5 . In the late '90s when i was living in Germany, a cultural/television phenomenon had developed known as "Deutsche Schalger" (German Hits). The phenomenon amounted to old German crooners (and some unknown younger artists) singing classic German 'schmalz'. These shows were popular with young and old audiences alike, but the sense i got was that the youth audiences watched/enjoyed these shows 'ironically' while older audiences saw them nostalgically. This seems to me to parallel our earlier 'Monster Truck' conversation where indie culture can consume 'mainstream' (or trashy) culture 'ironically' and remain indie, but i'm curious where this line breaks down, or how/why we draw it (i thought of this around p. 43-44)

2.73 . on page 42, when a 2003 Chicago Tribune article that Wilson is citing makes such a big fuss about the use of the word titanic in Afghanistan... isn't "titanic" just a word that means big?

3. Wilson posits the idea of 'difficult listening' vs. 'easier [not easy] listening' as a possible explanation to why we hate Celine Dion (p. 20). This is an idea we've come to previously in this class, particularly when talking about indie rock & early REM, but i wonder if we haven't overlooked the promise of 'complicating' simpler texts. Why do we (or why does indie culture) preference the 'deep text', the text you have to work at in order to understand over the simple text that you have to work at to 'complicate'? I'm thinking here of the the distinction between avant-garde art that (at least at some point in its history) valued texts that were at least on the surface level utterly simple (such as Rauschenberg's "White Paintings" or Michael Snow's Wavelength), that were, essentially works of art without content. Their complexity comes, then, from how they are read by the viewer.

"Let's Talk about Love"

To me, Chapter 6 seems to be more of a criticism against the ways in which Celine Dion’s voice is in contact with the audience. Wilson would argue that it is essentially “a volume business” which identifies Dion’s music as a piece of luxurious commodity and a technical plus ethnic role model that both intimidates people into low-creativity and engenders didactics to persuade audience into mainstream incorporation. It looks like the critics of mainstream highlights the evaluation of the cultural impacts upon the receivers. Not only do they emphasize the quintessential values of the “high brow/low brow cultures”, but also are they highly concerned about what values the different cultures would bring to the mass audience. Wilson’s examination of Dion’s music indicates that mainstream may fall short in enriching the audience in terms of personality cultivation and perhaps creativity as well. In this regard, I was wondering would the music (or other cultural forms) community of subculture help improve the shortcomings that the mainstream fails to bring. If so, in what ways would subculture contribute to enhance the connections between cultural outcomings and audience in terms of the influence over the receivers?

Wilson also argues in the illustration of the case of Dion that corporate mainstream culture has become globalized and hybridized with indigenous cultures. In this sense, the globalization and hybridization in fact create a popular mainstream identity that is recognized by worldwide audiences in a variety of areas. It seems to me that this global commercialization in the form of popular music establishes such an “imagined community” that people from different countries with different cultural backgrounds are assimilated into this community and are together identified as “citizens” of pop music world. And yet, how would local subculture distinguish itself in front of the juggernaut of globalization? Would it see this trend as an opportunity to expand its sphere and connect to its outside counterparts communities by joining this “shrinking world?” Or, could it be that the globalization eventually erodes the autonomy of subculture and harms its chances for future development?

Off of my second question, I have long been struggling with the question that does the definition or conception of subculture designate to a more universal application wherein worldwide subcultural community members recognize and enjoy a commonality? Or could the term of subculture be redefined according to various geographical norms so that one mainstream cultural form might be transformed and localized into a culture of underground or non-mainstream? Wilson’s example on this issue is the Iraqi copycat of American Idol and the Iraqi barber fights all the way against all odds through the competition, which irritates the mainstream in Iraq. The fact is that when Dion’s mainstream music bothers critics at home, “My Heart will Go on” seems to arm the Iraqi barber with an identity of subcultural taste that separates him from mainstream. So what would we make of the story regarding the cultural transformation in this sense?

Friday, October 24, 2008

Céline Dion is amazing



Isn't she?

*

Carl Wilson has a blog, Zoilus.

The 33 1/3 series of books does too: 33 1/3. See also: Wikipedia.

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Oriental Theatre Images



Here are some pictures from a recent visit to the Oriental Theatre in Milwaukee for my Indie Culture Site assignment.























Indie Site: La Blogotheque

I'll be discussing the indie rock video site La Blogotheque in class.
I am posting a separate blog, with video examples and a little background on
the site, should any of you be interested.

http://mjbmutterings.blogspot.com/

Thanks,
Molly

The Pedal Pusher Society

It is important that I disclose my involvement with the site of indie culture that I chose to document. The Pedal Pusher Society (PPS) is Milwaukee’s premiere all girls and trannies bike gang, and I am one of four founding members. This group is incredibly dear to me, and I have been involved in its development and implementation on every level. It is challenging for me to speak objectively about the group, which is exactly why I wanted to use this opportunity to critically examine what PPS is and how we function in relationship to the larger underground bicycle culture.


The dominant underground bike culture in this city is a thriving independent culture. It promotes a healthy, sustainable lifestyle that is a direct rejection of the fundamentals of capitalism that fuel the mainstream’s automobile addiction. To begin to understand this culture and its values, the video After the Fall is a great entry point. The director, Marshall Pierce, is a member of the group he’s filming, and he summarizes his video as “A look at underground Bike Culture in a growing industrial city.”[1] The viewer is introduced to things that are important to this culture – road bikes in general, but fixed gear bicycles as an ideal (especially if it is somehow customized); the sport of bike polo; using the bicycle as a primary mode of transportation and also a means of employment. Pierce shows us these things by juxtaposing images of Milwaukee with clips of members of his culture speaking about and participating in that culture. These images and clips serve to highlight the greater subtext of the film - this is a culture that celebrates bad-assery [2] and competition among straight, white men.



After the Fall by Marshall Pierce. For a prime example of bad-assery, please view the exchange that begins at 7:34.


Despite the proclamation that this is an examination of Milwaukee’s underground bike culture, at no point in the video is a woman featured as a cultural participant. What is the explanation behind this obvious gap? The dominant underground bike culture is extremely male dominated and heterocentric, and this video, made from within the culture, is a prime example of its exclusivity. Men have always been granted immediate access to this community, and they are privileged in having a support network already in place for them upon first entering. Women, on the other hand, must create a place for themselves, and it is exceedingly difficult for a woman to attain the same status that is automatically granted a man.[3] Women are simply not taken as seriously. That is why only one female bicycle messenger is employed in this city. That is why there are not any girls featured as cultural participants in this video. That is why the Pedal Pusher Society exists.


We formed PPS in 2005 as a direct response to the dominant underground bike culture. For many of our members, the Pedal Pusher Society is the first bike culture that has made them feel welcome and comfortable. We accept members no matter what their level of performance or type of bicycle, which is truly uncommon in bike culture. We have even taught ladies how to ride. Many of our most active members are women who were intimidated by city riding and wanted to practice in a supportive group. One of the more seasoned riders in the gang commented that she enjoys riding with PPS because “we know how to keep a steady pace without leaving anyone behind”. It seems that members of all ability levels find it empowering to help transform a normally exclusive culture into one that instead encourages more women to become actively involved in cycling.


One of the things I find most exciting about the Pedal Pusher Society is the ways in which we encourage that involvement. In creating PPS, our intention was not to carve out a place for ourselves in the dominant bike culture, but rather to create something different and new. So we focused on opening up bike culture to include other interests, in the hopes that PPS would not become as insular as the dominant bike culture. In so doing, we knew we would appeal to more women who might feel more comfortable being part of a culture that wasn’t just focused on bikes. When we plan rides, we try to cater to these multiple interests. We’ll go to farmers markets and then make lunch from our ingredients. Or we’ll end up at a member’s house for a dance party or campfire. We have also screen printed and hand-embroidered gang jackets, to serve as subcultural signifiers for our members. In this way, the Pedal Pusher Society has become an important social outlet for many of our members, and a culture they are truly invested in.


Interestingly, the events that tend to empower members the most are the making of music videos. In 2007, we decided we needed to find a creative way of inviting people to join the gang. Participation was lacking, and it seemed that this was due partly to the stigma that surrounds underground bike cultures. We were viewed as an underground bike culture, so we, too, must be exclusive. To bridge this gap, we decided we had to create something that went beyond the confines of normal bike culture, and the idea for Eye of the Tiger was born. It was filmed over the course of two evenings with a camcorder that we bought from Wal-Mart (due to their generous 30 day return policy on opened electronics). Most of the participants had never ridden with us before, but were somehow connected to the group through common acquaintances. We used the shoot as an excuse to get these people involved, in the hopes that they would want to continue to participate. It worked – many of the people in that video have become some of our most active members.[4] When asked why, credit is often given to their participation in the video - none of us had made a video before, and none of us knew what we were doing. It was the shared process of creation that fueled the group with a sense of accomplishment and community.



Eye of the Tiger by the Pedal Pusher Society.


Last summer, we made a new music video, with even more participants, this time set to Michael Jackson’s “Beat It” (and essentially a direct response to the original Michael Jackson video). The video portrays two rival girls bike gangs who are brought together by the benevolent Pedal Pusher Society. In both of our videos, the characters present both a parody of male toughness and an alternative to it. The women in the videos are allowed to occupy spaces and roles that are usually inaccessible to them in dominant society. In so doing, the Pedal Pusher Society is changing the sphere of bike culture and claiming new spaces for women outside of the dominant bike culture. This is an important point of cultural differentiation – PPS is not trying to carve out a place for women within the dominant bike culture. We’re trying to create something new, something that hasn’t existed before. This is essentially the mission of the Pedal Pusher Society – to create a supportive, independent culture while simultaneously having an awesome time.



Beat It by the Pedal Pusher Society. This is a very large file, so please let it fully upload before attempting to view - otherwise the video is jerky. You might miss the subtle nuances! Embedding of Michael Jackson's original video has been disabled, but if you'd like to see what we worked in response to, you can view it here.


By and large, PPS and our videos have been met with a great deal of support, from those within the larger underground bike community and also from people functioning wholly outside of that culture. But the fact that PPS exists is very threatening to some male cyclists, as their exclusion from any area of underground bike culture is unprecedented. On a web community where the Beat It video was posted, one male cyclist responded by saying “If I start a bike club and hang a big sign on the metaphorical door that says 'boyz only, girls keep out' that would be wrong, right?”[5] The fact of the matter is that men don’t have to hang that sign on their club’s metaphorical door. The dominant underground bike culture is a definitive boy’s club – the message of that sign is enforced without it being there, resulting in the systematic exclusion of women, or any other group that would fall within an “other” category.


I always detest it when authors skirt around issues of race and queerness in their work, acknowledging that problems are present, but refusing to take the space to examine them. Nevertheless, I find that this is what often happens within the Pedal Pusher Society. As an example, I want the spaces we create to be open to people who are transgender. I have pushed this agenda on the group, touting PPS as Milwaukee’s premiere girls and trannies bike gang. But our inclusion of trans folks has ended there – we haven’t gone to any other lengths to make the space welcoming. I worry about what would happen if an out trans person showed up for a ride. On the one hand, I would be absolutely elated – I have experienced transphobia and I desperately want PPS to function as a space that is inclusive beyond the traditional gender binary (and also to not define itself in terms of that binary). On the other hand, I would be horrified that gender queer individuals might be pummeled with questions regarding their identity or of who they “really” are. Furthermore, what would it mean for the group’s perceived identity? These are questions and issues that have not been properly dealt with and, frankly, need to be.


It should also be noted that the experience of this culture is more or less limited to people residing within the confines of Riverwest and Bay View. While we usually take our rides well outside these areas, our outreach efforts end there. Consequently, our culture is predominantly young, and mostly white. This certainly impacts our agenda and the group dynamic. In an effort to diversify the group, we have talked about hosting a series of workshops around the city that aim to educate women about safe urban cycling skills. We would also like to hold open “fix-it” sessions in which we use our collaborative knowledge to repair bikes. These ideas are good ones, but I’m not sure how effective they would be.


There is a need for an alternative to the dominant underground bike culture. The Pedal Pusher Society actively works to help fill that need. I feel strongly that, even when we’re not riding, PPS is fulfilling its mission, because it’s helping more and more people to become empowered cyclists. There are so many other bike subcultures that would be a boon to cycling, and my greatest hope is that the Pedal Pusher Society would help to empower individuals to start these subcultures. In essence, that’s what we did – we saw a need, and we responded to it.


For more information, or to join, or to stare at pictures of us, please check out our not oft-updated website, our myspace page or these flickr photosets (set 1, set 2)



[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ivtP1Ihg1qA, accessed October 20th, 2008.


[2] Colloquial as this seems, I believe it provides the most accurate description. Traditional “masculinity” is not specific enough.


[3] There is the possibility that men might find it challenging to access this community, but exclusion would be due an obvious violation of subcultural style (for instance, riding an upright bicycle, or something equally uncool). A woman, on the other hand, might be in possession of all the subcultural tools of the trade, but she will still have to fight for a place in this culture.


[4] Most of our other members are women who saw the video and wanted to take part in the culture we created. Our e-mail list jumped from about 20 to over 90 after Eye of the Tiger was released.


[5] http://www.metafilter.com/74328/this-is-bad, 15th comment, accessed October 20th, 2008.





Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Independent Gaming Examples

Here are three examples at Indiecade that I think represent distinctly indie aesthetics in gaming.

And Yet It Moves



The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom



Dark Room Sex Game

Monday, October 20, 2008

Brew City Bruisers Video

I've been trying desperately to get this video properly updated, I think this may be it. Anyway, I was going to show this video during the presentation but thought this would be more convenient.

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Caught in a (handmade) Rat Trap: On Cynicism and Incorporation

Read Frank’s “Why Johnny Can’t Dissent” and it becomes abundantly clear he subscribes to, like Hebdige, Gramsci’s notion of Hegemony and co-optation. However, Frank explains, “What’s happened is not co-optation or appropriation, but a simple and direct confluence of interests.” He argues that modern day dissent is ineffective preciously because its tradition, dating back to the Beats, has long ago been assimilated into corporate culture. It seems, Frank might argue, the only thing separating the hippy on Wisconsin Avenue holding a sign for Revolution and the hippy in a boardroom, singing the same mantra to his colleagues, is not a desire for change or rebellion, but their venue. With that in mind, and considering Walker’s “Handmade 2.0” article, it seems indie crafters aren’t opposed to the fetishism of brands, styles, and unique products, they’re just opposed to that fetishism if it’s for corporate products. In other words, are these Indiepreneurs just future corporate moguls who have not yet risen to power? Is there a difference between Nike and aNYthing? Are hip, rebellion, and counterculture, as Frank suggests, really things that can be co-opted? And if so, what separates the motive of A-Ron from the motive of MTV?

Side Question: In this way, Frank comes off as cynical and uncritical of the motives the capitalist might have in comparison to the grassroots organizer. If Frank is right to call for a change in the culture of dissent, what might it look like? Is the rebellious culture propagated in office complexes really analogous to the counterculture of the 60s, which, unlike profit-motivated corporations, sought egalitarian principals?


Frank attacks the recent trends of cultural studies when he proclaims all the contextual readings of Madonna – as a woman who bends notions of sexuality, gender, and race - as nothing more than the academizing of public relations. He more than suggests that cultural theorists, as well as anybody who has an affinity for Madonna, are simply dupes playing into the corporate game of modifying, packaging, and selling notions of rebellion or alternativeness to the masses. Of course, what gives his musings an element of humor is how accurate he is in some of his barbed observations. However, the alternative he does offer to what he calls “popular culture” is shrouded in its own smoke of elitism and mystery. What is this “well-screamed no” he describes? A subculture so underground that it’s beyond aesthetics, beyond labels, beyond any tangible or ethereal element that could otherwise be adopted by corporate interests? Can DIY culture fit into this conception, or does the simple act of making something physical, and thus identifiable and marketable, contradict the ethereal resistance Frank speaks of? Are these the ramblings of a disaffected, alienated, nihilistic, bitter subculturist, or can these ideas be grasped and grounded to become something other than the lofty threats of a precocious underground man?

Finally, what subcultural attributes can we attach to the term Indiepreneurs? Hebdige argues one main quality of subcultures is their youth. However, Walker mentions that the average age of many DIY crafters is 34. What about the quality of resisting the parent culture? The mainstream? In this case, can these things be likened to Corporate Culture? Finally, if the aesthetics of this DIY culture have already been or will soon be incorporated into future corporate product lines, what distinguishes these products as subcultural? Is it the handmade process of production? Is it the economic restrictions on the creators? Are the politics, which are “against the dehumanizing global supply chain” important? In other words, are these Indiepreneurs, or just garden-variety DIY entrepreneurs?

Monday, October 13, 2008

in today's USA Today...

http://www.usatoday.com/money/industries/retail/2008-10-12-karmaloop-selkoe_N.htm

This story is from today's USA today's Money section. I grabbed my free USA Today at the Library and
found this article to be pretty relevant to what we're reading... so I am posting a link. Hmmm...
Molly

Thursday, October 9, 2008

Reading Questions: Hip + DIY Consumerism (For 10/15)

1. A reoccurring theme in most of the readings we’ve analyzed thus far is that of authenticity. In his article, “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction,” Walter Benjamin argues that “The unique value of ‘authentic’ work of art has its basis in ritual, the location of its original value” (p.4). In other words, a piece of art is intrinsically linked with a culture’s (or subculture’s) history. In Rob Walker’s article, “Handmade 2.0,” the founder of “the online shopping bazaar Etsy,” Robert Kalin, is quoted as saying, “When you get an item from Etsy, there’s this whole history behind it. There’s a person behind it” (p.6). If a product is handmade and/or original, does that increase the value of the work of art? If so, why does this matter to certain consumers? Is it mainly because of social status, or does it voice a political statement of some sort, such as the fact that the handmade nation carries out a more personal, environment-friendly business? (See p.1)

2. In his article, “Alternative to What?” Thomas Frank argues that countercultural entrepreneurship is part of the “rebel ideology that has fueled our culture ever since the 1960s” (p. 149). In “The Brand Underground,” Walker introduces us to several young grass-roots brand-maker entrepreneurs who carry out the rebel ideology: A-Ron and his “aNYthing” t-shirts, Daniel and Michael Casarella and “Barking Irons,” and Bobby Kim and Ben Shenassafar’s “The Hundreds.” Walker exemplified the rebel ideology when he quoted Bobby: “‘It’s just the idea of trying to be rebellious,’ he said. ‘Or trying to be a little bit anti, questioning government or your parents. Trying to do something different’” (p.7). How does this (rebel) entrepreneurial ideology compare to that of music subcultures? Is this ideology as much of a political statement as what the punks were trying to do with their torn t-shirts? (See Hibdige.) How does it compare to indie rock’s DIY ethic? (See Hibbett p.61) Further, how does the fact that A-Ron dropped out of high school and was still successful play into the rebel ideology?

3. In “The Brand Underground,” Walker examines minibrands and “quasi art objects”—sneakers as form of expression (p.8). He emphasizes the fact that corporations are working with the counterculture to make a new product. Walker states, “Instead of stealing ideas from the underground, the big sneaker makers positioned themselves as supporting it. The strategy seems to work” (p.8). For instance, graffiti writers Futura and Stash designed co-branded products with Nike. However, doesn’t a co-optation lower a hip product’s subcultural capital? Should fans be upset that Futura and Stash co-opted if the reason they did so was to keep their lifestyle-as-a-business dreams alive? Walker notes that “sneakerheads were willing to treat athletic shoes made by multinational corporations as cultural objects” (p.9). Why were they willing to see this collaboration as cultural objects? Was it because it’s a good business decision for both parties? In other words, on the one hand, Nike gets a new, hip product and makes a lot of money while showing it supports underground ideas. While on the other hand, Futura and Stash get wider recognition, a potentially larger audience, and a portion of the profits.

Hip & DIY consumerism week, websites etc.

Re Walker, Handmade 2.0:

Buy Handmade

Craft magazine
/Getcrafty

Some local Etsy shops:

rosybird

Tattoo Annie

Fasten Collective

Handmade Nation stuff:

blog

promotional merchandise at Etsy

official website




opening credits stop-motion sequence

***

Re Walker, The Brand Underground:

Things Walker discusses:

aNYthing

Barking Irons

The Hundreds

Beautiful Losers (Wikipedia)/official site of the film

Other t-shirt stuff online:

Threadless

Tcritic

***

Updated 10/15, examples for class...



A Threadless design, "The Communist Party"





IBM commercials discussed by Frank, "Why Johnny Can't Dissent," p. 40

Two works by the graffiti artist ESPO:



A roll-down job in Queens, NYC.



Nike Air Force II ESPO

Article on DIY Craft Movement

Hey there,
I just thought I'd share this article from The Leader that I came across. It's all about the Do-It-Yourself craft movement and the documentary Handmade Nation that is set to come out in early 2009.
------------
Crafty lady brings DIY spirit to the nation
Allison Hellweg
http://media.www.uwmleader.com/media/storage/paper980/news/2008/10/02/Featuresnews/Crafty.Lady.Brings.Diy.Spirit.To.The.Nation-3469369.shtml
------------
Enjoy.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

More questions about Club Culture

1. Thornton listed the differences between mainstream ideologies and subculture ideologies with a schema on P115. Is it an indication that Club culture holds its distinction based on discrimination towards mainstream ideologies? How to understand the relation between such a distinction and discrimination? And does this schema accurately and inclusively reveal all the differences between club culture ideologies and popular ideologies? Among the 12 factors, which do you think is most essential one for these clubber and raver to identify “US” from “THEM”?

2. According to Thornton, even though clubber or raver claim their culture as classless, they use subcultual capital as the linchpin of an alternative hierarchy “in which the axes of age, gender, sexuality and race are all employed in order to keep the determinations of class, income and occupation at bay”(P105). To be specific, “despite their discourses of liberty, raves had distinct demographics-chiefly white, working-class, heterosexual and dominated by the lads.”( P25) And there are 3 principles in the organization of club: self-selection, routes of communication, and door policy (P110-114). At this point, can we assume club culture has comparatively more "autonomy”? Can we say that club culture maintains absolute “classlessness”? And can clubs and raves democratize youth culture? Why/ Why not? Considering its social meaning, does the “hierarchy” in club culture equal to “class” in mainstream culture to indicate status? How to understand the relation between the two from the perspective of social logic of cultural capital and subcultural capital?

3. Thornton talked about various media (mass media, micro media, and niche media) involved in the formation of club cultures. On P90, Thornton mentioned a typical club whose culture is outlaw but its antagonist “is not the police but the media who continually threaten to release its cultural knowledge to other social groups”. So positive tabloid coverage is “the subcultural kiss of death” (P135). On the other hand, “mass media ‘misunderstanding’ is often an objective of certain subcultual industries, rather an accident of youth cultural pursuit.” (P136) Does it mean that club and rave can take advantage of or even seek for negative reporting and avoid “positive tabloid coverage” for its further development? How can clubs and raves invoke the negative reporting against positive coverage? How can they control the tongue of media coverage? Is it risky for subculture to get media involved?

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Club Questions

1. Thornton continues throughout the book to define youth culture in the music scene. “Youth tend to have specialist music tastes with strong preferences for hip-hop, indie, or hardcore dance.” (20) Is her statement about the music taste of youth relevant today? Do they really tend to have specialized taste? Pop music? Thornton discusses in her analysis of the club scene that legal drugs such as liquor are used to symbolize the accomplishment of adult status and illegal drugs used to reject adult culture. Does this mean that to be a part of club culture you need to rebel against the adult norms in society? Are youths really thinking this deeply about their recreational usage when partaking in the club scene? Is the use of illegal drugs just the result of the curiosity of youths for the unknown combined with the feeling of invincibility that is often experienced by young people in terms of their conception of their own mortality?

2. Thornton opens up chapter two with a discussion on authenticity which leads into the way production and consumption of music has evolved over time. It’s interesting to think that before recorded music, the only music was live and in person. “Initially, records transcribed, reproduced, copied, represented, derived from and sounded like performances.” (27) This got me thinking of a few moments in my brief existence when I have purchased an album of a band I heard on the radio or was referred to by someone, and then shortly after, attended one of their shows. To my complete and utter disappointment the live concert version of their music sounded like crap which led me to quickly abandon those bands. Have you ever found yourself experiencing something similar? Is it important that the live experience is similar to what has been recorded? Is this the driving force of authenticity? “In the process of becoming originals, records accrued their own authenticities. Recording technologies did not, therefore, corrode or demystify ‘aura’ as much as disperse and relocate it.” (27) Do you agree with what the author is saying and how is this significant to the evolution of how authentic music is defined today?

3. In chapter 3, Thornton is attempting to define the mainstream through the guise of her ethnographic experience with clubbing. I found myself questioning how authentic and true her portrayal really was considering that it was largely out of character for her to participate in the things that are representative and definitive of the club culture she is describing. She says in her conclusion, “for many youthful imaginations, the mainstream is a powerful way to put themselves in the big picture, imagine their social world, assert their cultural worth, claim their subcultural capital. As such, the mainstream is a trope which betrays how beliefs and tastes which ensue from a complex social structure, in turn, determine the shape of social life.” (115) Is this conclusion valid in terms of her ethnographic experience and scholarly research? Does Thornton’s conclusion represent what is the mainstream today in terms of club culture and youth?

Sunday, October 5, 2008

Just an interesting article I'm posting

http://nymag.com/anniversary/40th/50666/

I am reading this in my current issue of New York Magazine. It's so interesting and relevant to some of our discussions.
Hope you enjoy it.
Molly

Friday, October 3, 2008

Is it a joke about drugs or sociology?

Decide for yourself on page 89! I know, that makes four questions, and now I'm setting the bar all high for everybody else. But I'm going to give that one to y'all for free, no strings attached. Ok?

Thornton takes great care to point out that discotheques “tend to duplicate structures of exclusion and stratification found elsewhere.” (25) Even within the subculture, hierarchies are present. There are exclusive VIP lounges, differences in drug quality, and a clubber’s inclusion in future events is based on connections made within the current club. Thornton begins her first person account with “Kate”, a woman we quickly learn is highly connected in the club scene. Kate is able to take Thornton to places she never would have gained access to on her own. How is Thornton’s ethnographic study colored by her immediate inclusion in the VIP community of the club subculture? Do you think this affects her work as a whole? What problems or benefits could this have created within her research?

Thornton repeatedly refutes the binaries that have been utilized by scholars within the sociological study of subcultures. At one point, she argues that the “multiple opposition” created by Hebdige in Subculture (i.e. Hebdige’s assertion that subcultures are reacting against the dominant as opposed to within it) is “an orderly ideal which crumbles when applied to historically specific groups of youth”. (93) To Thornton, these binaries do not allow for the intricacies of subcultural participation. Relating this idea back to the specific groups discussed in Subculture, do you think that work would have benefited from Thornton’s analysis?

Through her interpretation of Bourdieu, Thornton coins the term subcultural capital, which she defines as the “means by which young people negotiate and accumulate status within their own social worlds.” (163) Why is it important that Thornton chose to create the idea of subcultural capital instead of working within Bourdieu’s idea of cultural capital? What are the differences between cultural and subcultural capitals?

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Indie rock questions

1, I consider indie rock began to separate itself from alternative rock when Nirvana tried to have some impact on the mainstream, which later became commercialized and marked a big success and others stayed underground. As Johnson says “Economic profit is normally disavowed (at least by the artists themselves), and the hierarchy of authority is based on different forms of symbolic profit…” (Quoted; Hibbett, 57). However, Hesmondhalgh argues that “the logic of the music industry as a cultural system is towards internationalization, because of the economies which accrue to very big, as opposed to moderate, sales…but such economics are not enough in themselves to explain what happened in indie in the late 1980s”. Is the economic situation of the band can be a criterion to define whether it is in the group of indie rock bands or not? And how can the band keep the balance between the profits from mass audience or just the band itself, for example some from the sales of albums or some just make profit from tickets income? Are there any specific boundaries within all indie rock bands between those bands are commercialized and those are not?


2. As the musicians and fans gradually remolded the alternative rock or rock music into a new form of serious hardcore, the whole process is shaping the music genre which became indie rock more predictable and testosterone-driven. Hibbett also says “indie rock requires its own codes, i.e. cultural capital, and therefore can be used to generate and sustain myths of social or intellectual superiority”. (57) By saying this and gives the example of “Soyouwanna Fake Being an Indie Rock Expert?” , how to connect people’s factual knowledge and their social savvy if the goal is just “faking” rather than Bourdieu’s “being” somebody else? Is the also a way to say that some of Bourdieu’s distinctions between classes are so static that people don’t even have a chance to change or even to fake?


3, In the 1990s, the indie music divided into different subgenres like indie pop, dream pop, math rock, space rock, sadcore and so on. How can those subgenres maintain their own positions and make the underground phenomenon in a balanced situation? In Hongkong, Taiwan and mainland China, the concept of indie was explored too much by those songwriters and audience. A song called The Lament of Indie indicates how embarrassing the place indie music is in the current Chinese music industry and how they are struggling to survive. When talking about the regional identification, does the whole indie music will face the problem of searching “an artistic ‘elsewhere’”(Hibbett, 65) or just indie rock in this case?